Making Young’s Modulus Actually Teachable

Hemel Private Tuition – Practical Physics that Works

Young’s modulus is one of those A-level Physics experiments that ought to be conceptually beautiful but, in practice, often turns into a frustrating exercise in squinting at a vernier scale and arguing about micrometres.

Traditionally, students measure the extension of a long metal wire under load, often using a vernier scale or travelling microscope. It is technically correct — but also:

• fiddly

• time-consuming

• prone to large percentage uncertainties

• difficult for weaker practical students

• and not especially engaging

A Better Approach: Lascells Strip & Wire Testing Clamps

Using Lascells Strip & Wire Testing Clamps, we can transform the experiment into something that is:

• clear

• visual

• safe

• cheap

• and far more effective for teaching the physics rather than the micrometry

Instead of metal wires, students test plastic strips cut from carrier bags from different manufacturers. The behaviour is immediately visible, repeatable, and ideal for identifying key material properties.

---

The Physics You Can Actually See

With increasing load, students can clearly observe:

• Elastic behaviour – the strip returns to its original length

• Limit of proportionality – extension no longer proportional to force

• Elastic limit – permanent deformation begins

• Ultimate tensile strength – the maximum force before failure

These concepts are often abstract when using metal wires. With plastic strips, they are obvious.

---

Full Experimental Method

Apparatus

• Lascells Strip & Wire Testing Clamps

• Plastic carrier bags (cut into uniform strips)

• Metre ruler or fixed scale

• Mass hanger and slotted masses

• Clamp stand

• Safety tray (to catch masses if the strip fails)

---

Method

1. Prepare the sample

   • Cut strips of equal width (e.g. 10 mm) from different plastic bags

   • Measure the original length $L_0$

2. Set up the clamps

   • Secure the plastic strip vertically between the Lascells clamps

   • Attach the lower clamp to a mass hanger

3. Apply load gradually

   • Add masses in equal increments (e.g. 50 g or 100 g)

   • After each addition, measure the extension

4. Record data

   • Force (N)

   • Extension (m)

   • Note any permanent deformation on unloading

     

5. Continue loading

   • Until the strip clearly leaves linear behaviour

   • Stop just before failure (or allow failure with eye protection and clear space)

---

Results and Analysis

Typical Results Table

Load (N)	Extension (mm)
0.5	2
1.0	4
1.5	6
2.0	8
2.5	11
3.0	15

Graph

• Plot Force vs Extension

• The straight-line region shows Hooke’s Law

• The point where the graph curves marks the limit of proportionality

Discussion Points

• Why different plastics behave differently

• Why metals show a much smaller elastic region

• Why this experiment has larger extensions but smaller uncertainties

• Why real engineers test polymers differently from metals

---

Why This Works Better Than the Traditional Wire Method

✔ No microscopes
✔ No long wires under tension across the lab
✔ No students struggling to read verniers
✔ No huge uncertainty in extension measurements
✔ Far safer — especially for mixed-ability groups
✔ Much cheaper equipment
✔ Much quicker
✔ Much clearer physics

For teaching Young’s modulus as a concept, this approach is outstanding.

---

How We Use This at Hemel Private Tuition

In our laboratory and online TV-studio lessons, this experiment:

• reinforces material properties visually

• builds confidence in graph interpretation

• supports exam-quality evaluation answers

• works brilliantly for OCR, AQA, and Edexcel specifications

Students leave understanding why materials behave as they do — not just how to fill in a table.

 

Complex Numbers – From Argand Diagrams to Real Problems

Complex numbers often feel like a strange detour in A Level Maths. Students meet the imaginary unit $i$, are told that $i^2 = -1$, and may reasonably ask: why do we need this?

The answer is that complex numbers are not just mathematical curiosities. They are essential tools in engineering, physics, electronics, signal processing, and control systems. Understanding them opens the door to solving problems that cannot be handled using real numbers alone.

---

What Is a Complex Number?

A complex number has the form:

$$z = a + bi$$

where:

• $a$ is the real part

• $b$ is the imaginary part

• $i = \sqrt{-1}$

Every complex number can be represented as a point on a plane, rather than a point on a line.

---

Argand Diagrams – Seeing Complex Numbers

An Argand diagram plots:

• the real part on the horizontal axis

• the imaginary part on the vertical axis

For example, the complex number $3 + 4i$ is plotted at the point (3, 4).

This visual representation helps students understand:

• addition and subtraction of complex numbers

• magnitude (modulus)

• direction (argument)

---

Modulus and Argument

Modulus

The modulus of $z = a + bi$ is the distance from the origin:

$$|z| = \sqrt{a^2 + b^2}$$

This links complex numbers directly to Pythagoras’ theorem.

Argument

The argument is the angle the line makes with the positive real axis:

$$\arg(z) = \tan^{-1}\left(\frac{b}{a}\right)$$

Together, modulus and argument allow complex numbers to be written in polar form.

---

Polar Form and Multiplication

A complex number can be written as:

$$z = r(\cos \theta + i \sin \theta)$$

In this form:

• multiplying complex numbers multiplies their moduli

• adds their arguments

This makes problems involving powers and roots far simpler than using algebraic form.

---

Real Problems Where Complex Numbers Matter

1. Alternating Current (AC) Circuits

In physics and engineering, complex numbers represent:

• voltage

• current

• impedance

They allow phase differences between voltage and current to be handled cleanly.

---

2. Waves and Oscillations

Complex exponentials model:

• sound waves

• light waves

• oscillations

What looks abstract in maths becomes practical in physics.

---

3. Rotations and Transformations

Multiplying by a complex number can represent a rotation and scaling in the plane — a powerful idea used in graphics and robotics.

---

4. Solving Polynomial Equations

Some equations have no real solutions.
For example:

$$x^2 + 1 = 0$$

Complex numbers ensure that every polynomial has a solution, a result known as the Fundamental Theorem of Algebra.

---

Why Students Struggle – and How to Fix It

Students often struggle because:

• the imaginary unit feels artificial

• links to real applications are not always shown

• diagrams are not used enough

Using Argand diagrams, geometric interpretations, and applied examples transforms complex numbers from abstract symbols into useful mathematical tools.

---

Skills Highlight

• Plotting complex numbers on Argand diagrams

• Calculating modulus and argument

• Converting between algebraic and polar form

• Using De Moivre’s theorem

• Applying complex numbers to real-world contexts

---

Why It Works in Teaching

Complex numbers reward visual thinking and pattern recognition. Once students see that multiplication corresponds to rotation and scaling, many problems become simpler — not harder.

They also prepare students for further study in mathematics, physics, engineering, and computing.

 Measuring Half-Life with a Simulated Radioactive Decay Model

A safer (and still fascinating) way to explore nuclear physics in the classroom.

---

☢️ What Is Half-Life?

The half-life of a radioactive substance is the time it takes for half the atoms in a sample to decay.
It’s a key concept in understanding radioactivity, nuclear medicine, archaeology (hello, carbon dating), and more.

But since bringing a pot of uranium into a school lab tends to cause… concern… we use simulations.

---

🎲 The Classic Classroom Simulation

A tried-and-tested method to model radioactive decay is using dice, coins, or counters to represent unstable atoms.

Here’s how it works:

1. Give each student/group 300 coins (or paper squares, Lego bricks, etc).

2. Each coin is an atom.

3. Toss them all — every coin that lands “heads” has decayed.

4. Remove decayed coins. Count the undecayed ones.

5. Repeat the process for several “time intervals” (throws).

6. Plot number of undecayed atoms vs. timE

7. Compare one set of results with the rest of the class - they will be remarkably similar.

8. Compare this to playing with 4 stud LEGO bricks, where the decayed particle is a LEGO brick the correct way up, a different rate but the same result.

---

📉 What You’ll See

You’ll get a lovely exponential decay curve.

It won’t be perfect (radioactive decay is random), but it illustrates the statistical nature of half-life beautifully.

You can even:

• Calculate an experimental half-life

• Compare different simulations with different starting numbers

• Discuss sources of error and real-life limitations

---

💡 Why It Works

This model helps students grasp:

• That decay is random for each nucleus

• That half-life is about probability, not a countdown

• That decay rates are measurable over time, even if individual events are unpredictable

---

🧠 Extension Ideas

• Use multisided dice instead of coins (e.g., only 1s decay = longer half-life)

• Graph multiple runs and compare mean curves

• Link the activity to real-life isotopes like carbon-14 or iodine-131

• Use spreadsheets or PASCO sensors to enhance digital analysis

---

🔬 Final Thought

Understanding half-life doesn’t require radiation – just curiosity and some coins.

 

Natural Selection in Action – Modelling Evolution with Peppered Moths

Natural selection can feel abstract when students first encounter it in GCSE and A Level Biology. Terms like selective pressure, variation, and allele frequency are easy to memorise but harder to visualise.

The classic peppered moth example brings evolution to life. It shows natural selection happening over a short timescale, driven by environmental change and differential survival — exactly what Darwin described.

---

The Peppered Moth Story

The peppered moth exists in two main forms:

• light-coloured (typica)

• dark-coloured (carbonaria)

Before the Industrial Revolution, most tree trunks were pale and covered in lichens. Light moths were well camouflaged, while dark moths were easily spotted and eaten by birds.

As industrial pollution increased, soot darkened tree bark and killed lichens. Suddenly, the dark moths were better camouflaged. Birds ate more light moths, and the frequency of the dark form increased dramatically.

When air quality improved later in the 20th century, the trend reversed.

This is evolution by natural selection in action.

---

Modelling Natural Selection in the Classroom

Students can model this process using a simple practical or simulation.

Equipment:

• Paper moth cut-outs in two colours (light and dark)

• Two backgrounds (light paper and dark paper)

• Timer

• Data recording sheet

---

Method:

1. Scatter equal numbers of light and dark moths onto the background.

2. Act as the “predator” and remove moths you can see easily within a fixed time.

3. Count the remaining moths of each colour.

4. Repeat the process over several “generations”.

5. Change the background to represent environmental change.

Students quickly see one colour becoming more common than the other.

---

Typical Results

Light background (pre-industrial):

• Light moths survive in greater numbers

• Dark moths are removed more quickly

Dark background (industrial):

• Dark moths survive better

• Light moths decline rapidly

Over repeated generations, the proportion of moths changes — not because individuals change, but because survival and reproduction are unequal.

---

Key Biological Concepts Reinforced

• Variation: moths exist in different forms

• Selective pressure: predation

• Differential survival: better-camouflaged moths survive

• Inheritance: colour is genetically determined

• Change in allele frequency: populations evolve over time

This helps students avoid the misconception that organisms “adapt because they need to”.

---

Evaluation and Limitations

Students can critically evaluate the model:

• paper moths do not move

• predators are human, not birds

• time scale is compressed

Despite this, the model clearly demonstrates the principle of natural selection and is highly effective for learning.

---

Why This Works in Teaching

The peppered moth example:

• links biology to history and environmental change

• is backed by real scientific evidence

• allows data collection and graphical analysis

• supports exam questions on evolution and selection

It shows evolution as an ongoing process, not just something that happened millions of years ago.

---

Skills Highlight

• Modelling biological processes

• Recording and analysing population data

• Interpreting trends over generations

• Applying theory to real-world examples

• Evaluating experimental models

 

Social Stratification – How Class Shapes Opportunity

Social stratification refers to the way society is structured into layers, with unequal access to wealth, power, and status. In A Level Sociology, social class is one of the most important forms of stratification because it strongly influences people’s life chances — including education, health, employment, and social mobility.

Although modern societies often describe themselves as meritocratic, sociological evidence suggests that class background continues to shape opportunity in powerful and persistent ways.

---

What Is Social Stratification?

Social stratification is the hierarchical ranking of groups in society. These rankings are usually based on:

• economic resources (income, wealth, property)

• social status (prestige, lifestyle, cultural influence)

• power (the ability to influence decisions and institutions)

In the UK, class is often categorised using systems such as the NS-SEC (National Statistics Socio-economic Classification), which groups people based on occupation and employment relations.

---

How Class Shapes Life Chances

1. Education

Children from higher social classes tend to:

• attend better-resourced schools

• receive more educational support at home

• have greater access to tutoring and enrichment activities

• achieve higher exam results on average

Working-class students are statistically more likely to experience underachievement, exclusion, or early school leaving — not due to lack of ability, but due to structural disadvantage.

---

2. Health

There is a clear social class gradient in health:

• life expectancy is higher in professional and managerial groups

• working-class individuals are more likely to experience chronic illness

• access to healthy food, housing, and healthcare varies by class

Sociologists argue that poverty, stress, and occupational risk contribute significantly to these differences.

---

3. Employment and Income

Class background affects:

• access to high-status careers

• job security

• pay progression

• exposure to unemployment or precarious work

Professional networks, unpaid internships, and cultural familiarity with workplaces often advantage middle- and upper-class individuals.

---

4. Cultural Capital and Social Networks

Pierre Bourdieu argued that class advantage is reproduced through:

• cultural capital (language, tastes, knowledge, confidence)

• social capital (networks and connections)

These forms of capital help middle-class individuals navigate institutions more successfully, even when formal opportunities appear equal.

---

Sociological Perspectives on Stratification

Marxism

Marxists argue that class inequality is rooted in capitalism. The bourgeoisie control the means of production, while the proletariat sell their labour. Stratification benefits those who own wealth and exploits those who do not.

Functionalism

Functionalists suggest stratification is necessary to motivate people to fill important roles. However, critics argue this ignores inherited advantage and structural barriers.

Weberian Approaches

Max Weber saw stratification as multidimensional — based on class, status, and power, not just economic ownership.

Feminist and Intersectional Views

These perspectives emphasise how class interacts with gender, ethnicity, and disability, producing layered and unequal experiences of opportunity.

---

Is Social Mobility Possible?

While some individuals experience upward mobility, large-scale data shows that social mobility is limited. Many people remain in similar class positions to their parents, suggesting that opportunity is shaped more by background than by individual effort alone.

---

Skills Highlight

• Applying sociological theories to real social issues

• Using evidence to explain inequality

• Evaluating competing perspectives on class

• Understanding life chances and social mobility

• Developing analytical exam responses

---

Why It Works in Teaching

This topic connects sociology directly to students’ lived experience. It encourages critical thinking about fairness, opportunity, and the structure of society — and challenges the idea that success is purely the result of individual merit.

 

Is It Possible to Teach and Develop Augmented Reality (AR)?

A Level Computing

Augmented Reality (AR) is no longer a futuristic idea. It is used in navigation apps, medicine, engineering, retail, gaming, and education. Students interact with AR daily without realising it — through Snapchat filters, IKEA furniture previews, Google 3D animals, and the heads-up information on many smartphone apps.

So the question for teachers is: Can AR be taught and developed at A Level?
The answer is yes — at least at an introductory level — and doing so greatly enriches students’ understanding of computing, graphics, and real-world problem solving.

---

What AR Actually Involves

AR overlays digital information onto the real world using:

• a camera

• motion sensors

• computer vision

• 3D graphics

• a display (usually a phone or tablet)

In other words, AR sits right at the intersection of:

• programming

• mathematics

• physics

• digital design

• user interface development

This means it aligns beautifully with the aims of A Level Computing.

---

Why AR Is Worth Teaching

1. It connects computing with real-world innovation

AR powers:

• medical surgical overlays

• engineering diagnostics

• retail product visualisers

• educational science models

• live language translation apps

• architecture mock-ups

• tourism and museum guides

Students see computing as something that shapes the modern world.

2. It reinforces core A Level concepts

AR requires understanding of:

• coordinate systems

• vectors and transformations

• algorithms

• camera input handling

• data processing

• event-driven programming

These are all part of the specification, especially for OCR and AQA.

3. It motivates students who enjoy creative computing

AR development combines coding with design — perfect for learners who enjoy both technical and visual thinking.

---

How AR Can Be Taught at A Level (Realistically)

Students do not need to build a full AR engine. Instead, they can use accessible tools that abstract the difficult parts.

Option 1: Python + OpenCV (Basic AR Principles)

Students can:

• track markers

• detect shapes

• overlay simple graphics

• detect motion

• insert text or images based on camera input

This teaches the underlying computer vision concepts.

Option 2: Unity with AR Foundation (Industry Standard)

Unity is widely used in gaming and AR.
Students can:

• place 3D objects on real surfaces

• detect planes and anchors

• create AR educational tools

• design simple AR games

Unity development is approachable for A Level students with teacher guidance.

Option 3: Web-Based AR (Easiest to Deploy)

Using libraries like AR.js or Three.js, students can create AR experiences that run straight from a phone browser.

This requires:

• basic JavaScript

• simple 3D objects

• markers (printed QR-style patterns)

This is perfect for class demonstrations.

---

Possible Student AR Projects

• An AR model of the heart that labels structures when viewed with a phone

• A solar system model floating above a desk

• AR maths visualisations (vectors, graphs, transformations)

• A museum-style interactive poster

• An AR periodic table

• A simple AR scavenger hunt using markers around the classroom

• A revision tool where pointing a phone at a keyword reveals definitions

These projects are achievable and give students a sense of building something cutting-edge.

---

Challenges and Considerations

• AR requires relatively modern hardware

• Performance depends on lighting and device quality

• Teachers must introduce 3D coordinate systems

• Students need time to learn the tools

• Exporting apps can be tricky without licences

However, none of these challenges prevent delivering a meaningful, introductory AR curriculum.

---

Why Teaching AR Matters

AR is a major growth area in the tech sector.
Students who understand its principles gain:

• valuable insight into future careers

• experience in creative problem solving

• confidence in combining programming with design

• portfolio-ready projects that make UCAS and apprenticeships stand out

Teaching AR doesn’t require building the next Pokémon GO — it simply means giving students controlled, achievable experiences of how digital information interacts with the real world.

 

Testing Unknown Ions with Flame Tests

Nichrome wire and a Bunsen burner are not the only way to do this

Flame tests are a classic GCSE Chemistry method for identifying metal ions. When heated, certain metal ions produce distinctive flame colours — copper gives green-blue, lithium gives crimson, sodium produces an intense yellow, and so on.

Most students learn flame tests using a nichrome wire loop dipped in a sample and held in a Bunsen burner flame.
But this is only one method. There are several alternative approaches that can make flame testing easier, more reliable, or more accessible in different teaching environments.

---

The Science Behind Flame Tests

When metal ions are heated, electrons absorb energy and jump to higher energy levels.
As they fall back, they release energy as visible light, producing a characteristic colour.

Examples:

• Lithium → crimson

• Sodium → bright yellow

• Potassium → lilac

• Calcium → orange-red

• Copper → green/blue

This provides a quick, qualitative method for identifying unknown metal ions.

---

Traditional Method: Nichrome Wire and Bunsen Burner

Advantages:

• Cheap and simple

• Works well with solid salts

Disadvantages:

• Wire contamination causes mixed colours

• Cleaning the loop is time-consuming

• Strong sodium contamination often masks other colours

• Requires a full gas setup

Because of these limitations, alternative methods are often better for demonstration or classroom use.

---

Alternative Methods for Flame Testing

1. Wooden Splints

Soak splints in the metal solution and hold them in the flame.

Advantages:

• Cheap and disposable

• No cross-contamination

• Excellent for solutions rather than solids

Disadvantages:

• The splint burns, so colours may be short-lived

Works especially well for lithium, potassium, and copper.

---

2. Cotton Buds (Q-tips)

Dip the cotton end into a solution of the metal salt and place directly into the flame.

Advantages:

• Single-use

• No contamination

• Very easy for students

Disadvantages:

• Cotton may char, slightly dulling colours

Ideal for quick testing stations.

---

3. Metal Paper Clips (as an emergency nichrome substitute)

A standard steel paperclip can be bent into a loop and heated.

Advantages:

• Readily available

Disadvantages:

• Iron contamination may distort colours

• Not ideal for precise work

Useful only when other options are unavailable.

---

4. Lithium Chloride / Strontium Chloride Soaked Wicks (Demonstrations)

For spectacular demonstrations, chemists soak wicks in metal salt solutions and burn them.

Advantages:

• Bright, dramatic colours

• Great for whole-class viewing

Disadvantages:

• Not ideal for students to handle directly

• Requires careful safety control

Often used in flame-projector demos and firework chemistry workshops.

---

5. Using a Blue Glass Filter for Sodium Contamination

Sodium ions are everywhere — even in fingerprints — and they produce a strong yellow flame that overwhelms other ions.

A blue glass or cobalt filter cuts out sodium’s yellow emissions, allowing other ions (especially potassium’s lilac) to be seen clearly.

---

Interpreting Results

Students match flame colours with known ions, then use this to identify unknown samples.
Common ions tested at GCSE:

• Lithium (Li⁺) – red/crimson

• Sodium (Na⁺) – yellow

• Potassium (K⁺) – lilac

• Calcium (Ca²⁺) – orange-red

• Copper (Cu²⁺) – blue-green

These tests are often paired with precipitation tests for more reliability.

---

Why Flame Tests Matter

Flame tests help students understand:

• electron transitions

• emission spectroscopy

• qualitative analysis

• real-world uses in fireworks and metallurgy

They also develop careful lab technique and observational skills.

---

Skills Highlight

• Safe handling of flames and heated metals

• Avoiding contamination

• Interpreting qualitative chemical tests

• Using filters to isolate flame colours

• Linking observations to electron behaviour

---

Why It Works in Teaching

Students love the visual impact of flame colours. By exploring alternative techniques, they also learn about practical limitations, contamination control, and how professional chemists ensure reliable results.

It broadens understanding beyond the “nichrome loop” and builds confidence in chemical analysis.