Dragons’ Den Business Plans — What Would Make You Invest?
Someone asks you for £100,000 for 10% of their company. What would you want to know before saying yes?
On the table is an open equipment case. A phone drops into a clamp, a microphone plugs in and a small light comes on. Within a minute, a volunteer who has never filmed an interview is ready to press record. The demonstration earns a round of applause. Then somebody at the back asks the best business question of the morning.
“Who actually signs the order?”
Imagine you are the investor. The founder, the product and all the figures in this case are fictional. You can make an offer, ask the founder back with more evidence, or keep your money. Before reading on, write down the first question you would ask. See whether it is still your first question by the end.
A good idea in search of a buyer
Maya, a freelance film-maker, has designed First Take, a portable interview kit for secondary schools. The case holds a phone clamp, tripod, clip-on microphone, LED light and a laminated five-shot exercise. Schools supply their own compatible phone. Maya wants £100,000 to order stock, demonstrate the kit and establish the business.
I run a multi-camera studio, and the detail that interests me most is the laminated card. Give a beginner several cameras and a choice of microphones and there are plenty of ways to spend a lesson setting up. Give two pupils one microphone and the task “record a question and an answer that we can hear clearly”, and the equipment has an immediate purpose. A teacher might pay for those recovered minutes. I would want Maya to time a class setting up with her kit and then with equipment the school already owns. That would put a number on her best selling point.
Maya understands filming. Does she understand selling to schools? Ask her to talk through one trial from the first email to the invoice. Who used the kit? Who approved the money? Who rang her when the microphone failed to work with a school phone? Her answers reveal more about her strengths as an entrepreneur than a list of qualities such as “confident” and “determined”.
Twelve teachers like it. Two schools buy it.
Maya invites 12 media teachers from her professional network to a demonstration. Ten say they would use First Take. Four ask to borrow a kit. Two schools go on to pay the proposed £250 price for one kit each.
Which figure belongs at the top of her pitch? I would start with the two paid orders. Someone found room in a real budget. The four loans also deserve attention. A call to the two schools that borrowed a kit and returned it could uncover the most valuable finding of the trial. Did the product disappoint, did the department lack funds, or did the teacher who loved it lack purchasing authority? Each answer points to a different business decision.
At GCSE, this is primary market research. At A level, question how far the findings travel. Maya knew the teachers she invited. A head of department answering a cold email in a busy week may respond quite differently. For her next trial, give Maya a measurable objective: secure ten paid orders at £250 from schools outside her network within eight teaching weeks. Record how many schools she contacted, how many requested a demonstration and how long each sale took. That gives her both an objective and a way to learn from missing it.
How big is the market she can actually reach?
Maya forecasts sales of 600 kits in her first year. “There are plenty of schools” sounds plausible until you ask her to build the forecast from the ground up.
Suppose she can reach 300 suitable departments this year. If one in five places an order, that gives her 60 buying departments. To sell 600 kits, each would have to buy ten. So far, her two customers have bought one apiece. A ten-kit classroom order is possible, but it is a different purchasing decision from a teacher buying one for the department cupboard.
Give students a choice. Should Maya pursue large class sets, approach more schools, or lower her sales forecast? Each choice carries a cost. A larger order may need a discount. More demonstrations take time. A lower forecast makes it harder to cover the bills.
Then look in the cupboard. Maya’s competitors include equipment suppliers, teachers assembling their own kits, and the perfectly serviceable tripod already on the shelf. Ask a department to price the missing parts and try the same five-shot exercise. If the kit earns its premium through compatibility, quicker set-up and support, Maya needs to show the buyer what those advantages are worth.
Put the pitch through a break-even test
Use this simplified first-year forecast. The £150 variable cost includes components, assembly, packaging and delivery per kit. The £45,000 fixed costs include a founder’s salary and overheads. All figures use the same basis and the exercise ignores VAT, interest and tax.
| Forecast item | First-year figure |
|---|---|
| Selling price per kit | £250 |
| Variable cost per kit | £150 |
| Contribution per kit | £100 |
| Fixed costs | £45,000 |
| Break-even sales | 450 kits |
| Forecast sales | 600 kits |
| Forecast operating profit | £15,000 |
The first kit sells for £250. After its £150 variable cost, £100 is available towards the annual bills. That £100 is its contribution. It takes 450 such contributions to cover £45,000. Sell 600 kits and the remaining 150 contribute £15,000 of operating profit. Those 150 kits are also the forecast margin of safety, equal to 25% of forecast sales.
Now let a school buyer interrupt the pitch. “We’ll take a class set. Can you do £225 each?”
Pause before agreeing. If £225 became the price for every sale, contribution would fall to £75. Break-even would rise to 600 kits. At Maya’s original sales volume, a 10% price cut would wipe out the entire forecast profit.
One discounted order is a different proposition. If a school buys ten additional kits at £225 and Maya has spare capacity, the order contributes £750 towards overheads or profit, assuming the same unit cost and no extra fixed costs. If that school would have bought ten at full price anyway, the discount gives away £250. What would the customer have done without the discount? That is the question the arithmetic leaves for the entrepreneur.
Can she pay the supplier on Friday?
The first production run is 200 kits. For this cash-flow exercise, assume the whole £150 per kit must be paid before any customer receipts arrive. That means £30,000 goes out. Maya has £12,000 in the bank. Even if every kit eventually sells at full price, she is £18,000 short on payment day, before that month’s overheads.
This is where I would hand a student a calendar. Put the supplier payment on Friday. Put the school receipts six weeks later. Now point to the day the business needs help. An annual profit forecast cannot tell Maya whether her payment will clear on Friday.
It also raises an awkward question about the pitch. If the immediate gap is £18,000, why give up 10% of the company for £100,000? Ask Maya for a month-by-month cash forecast showing further orders, demonstrations, salaries and the lowest expected bank balance. A smaller first batch could reduce the immediate risk, although the supplier might charge more per kit. Negotiating staged supplier payments could buy time. The amount she raises should follow from what she needs to achieve before the cash runs out.
A-level extension — Where does the £1 million come from?
Assume the investor buys newly issued shares and the £100,000 goes into First Take. A 10% stake implies a post-investment valuation of £1 million.
£100,000 / 0.10 = £1,000,000 after investment.
£1,000,000 - £100,000 = £900,000 before investment.
That is the price implied by Maya’s offer. What evidence would persuade someone to pay it? At the forecast £15,000 operating profit, 10% is £1,500 on paper. Operating profit still has to cover any interest and tax, and the company might retain everything to finance its next batch. The investor could receive no dividend at all that year. Their case for investing may depend on future growth and eventually selling the shares. How likely is either if schools buy one durable kit and keep it for years?
Try a counter-offer of £100,000 for 20%. It implies a £500,000 post-investment valuation and leaves Maya with 80%, assuming she owned the whole business beforehand. From Maya’s chair, what could justify giving away the extra ten percentage points? An investor who can demonstrate a route into school purchasing networks may bring something she cannot buy with cash alone.
My verdict from the investor’s chair
I would invite Maya back after the eight-week trial. Two paying schools earn her a second conversation. The gap between one kit per buyer and the ten required by her forecast stops me writing the cheque today. I would particularly like to see the order form from a school that buys a second batch after using the first. It would tell me something no questionnaire has yet established.
A student could reasonably invest now. Perhaps the investor already supplies schools, can introduce Maya to department heads and can reduce the cost of reaching each buyer. To defend that verdict, the student needs to explain which assumption their involvement changes, by how much, and what happens if they are wrong.
That is how I approach GCSE and A-level Business at Hemel Private Tuition. We begin with a decision worth arguing about. We calculate the figure that matters, challenge an assumption and see whether our judgement survives. If your son or daughter can define break-even but finds “evaluate” questions difficult, this is the kind of work we can do together in Hemel Hempstead or online.
One final question for your own investor’s chair: which would do more to change your mind tomorrow morning — a survey with another hundred enthusiastic replies, or a purchase order for ten kits from a school Maya has never met? Why?






