A-Level Sociology Positivism, Interpretivism & the Nature of Social Facts

 

A-Level Sociology

Positivism, Interpretivism & the Nature of Social Facts

One of the most important debates in A-Level Sociology Research Methods is this:

Is society something we can measure objectively like a science…
or is it something we must interpret through human meaning?

At the centre of this debate are three key ideas:

• Positivism

• Interpretivism

• Social Facts

If students understand how these link together, essays become far easier to structure and evaluate.

---

1️⃣ Positivism – Sociology as a Science

Positivists argue that sociology should operate like the natural sciences.

Key thinkers:

• Auguste Comte

• Émile Durkheim

Core Beliefs:

• Society exists outside individuals.

• Social behaviour follows patterns and laws.

• We should use:

  • Statistics

  • Large-scale surveys

  • Official data

  • Experiments

Durkheim’s study of suicide is the classic example. He argued that suicide rates are social facts — measurable external forces influencing individuals.

---

2️⃣ What Are Social Facts?

Durkheim defined social facts as:

Ways of acting, thinking and feeling that exist outside the individual and exert control over them.

Examples:

• Laws

• Religion

• Education systems

• Marriage patterns

• Crime rates

These are:

• External

• Measurable

• Constraining

Positivists therefore favour quantitative data because it allows generalisation and reliability.

---

3️⃣ Interpretivism – Understanding Meaning

Interpretivists disagree.

Key thinker:

• Max Weber

They argue:

• Society is created through human interaction.

• People act based on meanings.

• We must understand behaviour through Verstehen (empathetic understanding).

Preferred Methods:

• Unstructured interviews

• Participant observation

• Case studies

• Qualitative research

Interpretivists argue that statistics don’t tell us why people act — only that they do.

---

4️⃣ The Core Exam Debate

Examiners love questions like:

“Assess the view that sociology should be a science.”

To access top marks:

• Explain positivism clearly

• Link to social facts

• Contrast with interpretivism

• Evaluate strengths and weaknesses

---

5️⃣ Evaluation Structure (PEEL Ready)

Positivism Strengths

• High reliability

• Representative samples

• Policy usefulness

Positivism Weaknesses

• Lacks depth

• Ignores human meaning

• May oversimplify behaviour

Interpretivism Strengths

• Rich, detailed data

• High validity

• Captures meaning

Interpretivism Weaknesses

• Hard to generalise

• Researcher bias

• Smaller samples

---

Why This Matters for Students

If you're studying A-Level Sociology in Hemel Hempstead or online:

Understanding this debate helps you:

• Analyse any research methods question

• Structure 20-mark essays

• Link theory to method

• Impress examiners with evaluation

In my 1:1 tuition sessions at Hemel Private Tuition, we practise:

• Turning theory into PEEL paragraphs

• Writing model introductions

• Building balanced evaluations

• Applying theory to unseen questions